This is a difficult topic. I'm not sure I can do it justice, but here goes.
What is "quality time"?
I have a feeling it is a relatively new concept.
For me, it brings to mind the image of Andy Griffith fishing with his son. Card games. Board games. Talking around the dinner table with your family. Summer vacations at the beach.
Mom, if you're reading this, hi. I seem to remember my mom telling me at one point that something she was taught was that smaller quantities of "quality time" with kids would outweigh/overcome the fact that work/life/etc would get in the way a certain amount of the rest of the time. I think the idea that was for working parents, especially working mothers, the message was that as long as the time you spent with your kids was "quality," it was good enough.
I wonder if historically in British/US culture, strict gender roles have deprived men of welcomed emotional expression (and emotional experience), leading many of them to cope by maintaining emotional distance, and/or drinking/raging. I wonder if the 1950s fantasy of Andy Griffith was in part a response to the absence of miserable fathers. I don't mean that they were bad fathers. I mean that they were miserable. I also wonder if the idea of "quality time" was invented as an antidote to the guilt parents feel for the times they are short with their kids, the times they are distracted. And when women started going to work, the conflict many felt over not being home with their kids may have been partially alleviated by the dream that sufficient "quality time" would fix any harm. The idealization of childhood may have also played a role in the development of the idea of "quality time." Financial success (and advertisers finding a huge market for the ideal lifestyle dream) led families to strive for perfection, not just in possessions, but in time expenditure, and the conflict between reality and the dream led to cognitive dissonance alleviated by the idea that sufficient "quality time" would fix any missteps.
I like to read about death. You know, when I need a pick-me-up (not really). But I seriously do read a fair bit about people dying. "The Diving Bell and the Butterfly" is a haunting yet powerful book about a man with locked-in-syndrome. He was driving to work one day, mid 30s as I recall (like me), had a stroke, and could suddenly only move his eyes and eyelids. That was it. He wrote the book by having a nurse point to letters and blinking when she pointed to the right ones. What I remember was that friends visited him at first, and then they gradually stopped visiting. I remember that he would experience the pleasure of being washed. Of course this is an extreme case, but what he focused on at the end had nothing to do with vacations at the beach. It was memories and experiences of the day to day, and love.
Another great read a few years back was "When Breath Becomes Air." It's about a neurosurgeon (again, my age, mid 30s) who got a brain tumor. He writes the book as he's getting sicker. Toward the end, it's getting harder for him to write, but he focuses on urging everyone reading the book to go and live while they can, to wake up from the stupor of sacrificing the present in hopes that it will lead to a successful future. For him, going through medical school was of course a huge sacrifice of life time. Was his time in medical school "quality time"? Was it worth the sacrifice? Did it "pay off"?
I took a bunch of psychology/education classes to get my teaching credential. Some of them were general, some of the geared toward special education. One class in particular, Adolescent Psychology, impacted me a lot. I remember learning two big ideas. One was that what kids need to thrive are 1) "unconditional positive regard" (love) and 2) consistent limits. The measure of parenting success did not consist of frequency of beach trips. The second big takeaway was that what kids need most is you. Simply for you to show up. It's not about what you do with them, it's about being there. I've got two little boys, and I've found this idea to be very helpful. When in doubt of what to do, I just sit down and look, listen, hold them. I don't have to take anyone fishing to be enough.
I'll tell you what isn't quality time, at least for me. Staying up late at night, sitting next to my husband, each of us on our phones looking at random crap online. I would say that 90% of what is done on my phone does not qualify as quality time, or even useful time. It is entertained time, but that's it. There is little to no personal connection occurring, no memories being made, no simplicities of life being savored. No boredom tolerated (and occasional boredom has been shown to be an important part of mental function, improving creativity, for example).
Sometimes when I want to evaluate something, I picture that I'm dying, and then ask whether I would want it. Like, is that paint color what I would want in my living room if I were to be lying in it next week, dying? I know it's a bit morbid, but it cuts to the chase sometimes for me to identify what I truly want.
One other thing I want to note- I remember learning in psychology classes that negative experiences stay with us much more than positive ones do. It isn't fair. But if someone you trust is trustworthy for 50 years, and then they lie to you, the one lie breaks the 50 years of trust. Parents who are patient, kind, patient, kind, and then yell or harshly spank their kid are remembered for their failure, not their success. I suppose it's a built in way to keep us safe- even if snakes don't bite us most of the time, the fact that they sometimes do bite us keeps us away.
Basically what this means for me is that quantity is more important than "quality," and if the striving for money to take the kids on vacation or the striving for the perfectly clean home or the striving for whatever else we're striving for makes me snap at the kids, it is definitely not worth the trade off. Irritability due to overwork or perfectionism will not get fixed by a trip to the beach. What my kids will remember about me is how I wake up in the morning, how I treat them day to day, not whether we played board games or not. It's sobering, but important.
The present is often not worth sacrificing for the future. There is a strong argument for enduring the stress of higher education; I'm not against that at all. But I think the focus should be on improving the experience of higher education so that it isn't so stressful. Having a sucky job to pay the bills is often necessary. We aren't elated all of our lives. But how can we improve that? How can we make jobs not be so sucky? How can we make the suffering we endure in order to reach our goals into a pathway that someone could die in the middle of and not feel that their limited hours had been wasted?
And can we all just turn off our phones?